Sadie's Ice Cream Parlor Menu

Sadie's Ice Cream Parlor at 1891 Cadotte Ave, nestled within Mackinac Island’s iconic Grand Hotel, offers a nostalgic treat for ice cream lovers. This charming parlor exudes a 1950s vibe, creating a cozy atmosphere ideal for indulging after exploring the island. The menu features classic and unique flavors like lilac—a floral-strawberry blend—and crowd favorites such as cookie dough, coffee, and black cherry. While the selection is somewhat limited, each scoop is refreshing and satisfying, perfect for a warm day out.

Customers appreciate the friendly, efficient service and the blend of indoor seating with some outdoor benches, offering a peaceful spot to enjoy the surrounding views. Portions are generous, though prices lean toward the higher end, a reflection of the tourist-heavy location. Overall, Sadie’s delivers a delightful, if somewhat pricey, ice cream experience that complements the historic and quiet charm of Mackinac Island.